Her voice did not sound like her own.

“It’s done. It’s too late. It was too late the day he asked her.”

“Yes,” Aunt Mab said, “it’s too late for that.”

She put out the claw of her hand and laid it over Alice’s.

“But it isn’t too late for you,” Aunt Mab said. “Not by a long way. You’re thirty-four, not a hundred, and there’s a duke at the inn who picked up his soup and walked the whole length of a table to sit next to you.”

She squeezed Alice’s hand.

“I’m deaf, child. I’m not blind.”

Alice found her sister in the still room the next morning. Cecily was looking for the rose water. She did not know where anything was kept. She had lived in that house for 22 years and never once opened the still room cupboards.

“Top shelf,” Alice said from the doorway. “On the left, behind the vinegar.”

Cecily jumped. Then she laughed.

“Oh, Ally, you frightened me. I don’t know how you find anything in here.”

“I’ve been finding things in here since I was twelve,” Alice said.

She came in and closed the door behind her.

“Cecily, what did you say to Julian at the gate?”

The laugh went out of her sister’s face as if someone had blown out a candle.

“What gate?”

“The front gate,” Alice said. “In May, the day he came home. While I was in the village paying Dr. Webb.”

Cecily reached up to the top shelf and took down the rose water. She did it slowly. She did not turn round.

“I don’t know what you mean,” Cecily said.

“Aunt Mab heard you yesterday,” Alice said. “In the drawing room, behind the screen. She isn’t as deaf as you think.”

Cecily’s hand stopped on the bottle. For a long moment, neither of them said anything. There was a fly bumping against the window. The kitchen clock ticked through the wall. Then Cecily put the bottle down on the table and she turned round and she said it.

“I heard you,” Cecily said. “Two summers ago by the pear tree. I was on the other side of the wall. I heard him ask you. And I heard you say, ‘Ask me again when Papa’s gone.'”

Her voice was quite steady.

“So when he came home, I got to him first. I told him you’d sworn never to marry. I told him you’d asked me to tell him. I told him not to make you say it to his face.”

Alice held on to the edge of the table.

“Why?”

“Why?”

Cecily laughed again, but there was nothing in it this time.

“Because it was always you, Ally. Always. Papa’s good girl. Papa’s nurse. Papa’s right hand. Everybody in this parish said, ‘Isn’t Alice wonderful? Isn’t Alice brave? Isn’t Alice a saint?’ Nobody ever said a single thing about me except that I was pretty. And then there was Julian, the only man who ever came to this house who was worth anything, and he was yours, too.”

“He wasn’t a thing to be had,” Alice said.

“No,” Cecily said, “he was a person, and he chose me. In the end, he chose me.”

“Because you lied to him.”

“Because you weren’t there,” Cecily said.

Her eyes were very bright.