Cecily told him with tears in her eyes that her sister had changed. She said the long years in the sick room had changed her. She said that when their father died, Alice had sworn on his coffin that she would never marry. Never. That she would stay in the house and keep it the way he had liked it for the rest of her life.
“She asked me to tell you,” Cecily said. “She didn’t have the heart to say it herself. She said you’d understand. She said, ‘Please, please don’t make her say it to your face. It would break her.'”
Julian stood by his horse for a long time without speaking. Then he said:
“I see.”
In a very quiet voice, he said:
“Thank you for telling me.”
He got back on his horse. He did not come up to the house. He rode back to the inn in the village and sat in his room there and did not come out for 2 days. On the third day, Cecily walked down to the village in her pale blue dress to see how he was. She went again the next day and the next.
6 weeks later, at the end of June, Julian Hart came to the Fenwick house for dinner. He was polite to Alice, very polite. He did not look at her once and at the end of the dinner he stood up and cleared his throat and asked Cecily to marry him. Cecily said yes before he had finished the question.
Alice did not make a scene. She sat at the dinner table while her sister cried with happiness and threw her arms around Julian’s neck. She sat there while the old cook, Mrs. Tilly, came in from the kitchen and burst into tears, too. She said all the right things. She said,
“I’m so happy for you both.”
She kissed her sister on the cheek. Then she went upstairs to her room and took the box of letters out from under her bed and sat on the floor with it in her lap until the candle burned down. She did not understand. That was the worst of it.
She went over it and over it and could not make it make sense. He had said he would wait years. He had written to her every month for 2 years. His last letter had come in April, only 6 weeks before he came home.
It had ended the way they always ended. ‘Two more months, Alice. Two more months and then I’ll ask you again.’ And then he had come home and he had not asked. He had not come to the house at all.
He had not even looked at her. She could only think of one reason. He had seen her somewhere in the village without her seeing him. He had seen what 11 years in a sick room had done to her.
She was 34. She had gray in her hair already, a streak of it over her left ear that she could not hide. Her hands were red and rough from washing sheets. She had forgotten how to dance.
She had forgotten how to talk about anything except medicine and the price of coal. And Cecily was 22 and golden and laughed at everything. Alice did not blame him. That was what she told herself, sitting on the floor with the letters.