Alice did not say anything.

“Instead, I found her at the door,” the Duke said, “holding twelve coats, and he was inside marrying her sister.”

He paused.

“I’ve been trying to understand it all afternoon. I can’t.”

“He changed his mind,” Alice said. “That’s all. It happens.”

“Does it?” the Duke said. “It didn’t sound to me like a man who was going to change his mind. It sounded like a man who’d have walked through fire.”

Alice looked down at the wet grass.

“Then maybe I changed,” she said. “Maybe he came home and saw me and saw what the sick room had done to me, and he changed his mind about that. I wouldn’t blame him.”

The Duke was quiet for a long time.

“Miss Fenwick,” he said at last, “I’ve been a widower for six years. I was married for fourteen before that to a woman who did not like me very much. I am not a man who notices very much about women. I haven’t had the practice.”

He turned his hat round in his hands.

“But I noticed you at the door before you knew who I was. You brushed the rain off me as if I were worth the trouble.”

He put his hat on.

“Nobody who has done that,” the Duke said, “has been ruined by anything.”

He bowed. He went back up the path to the house. Alice stood by the pear tree until the sun went in again.

The wedding breakfast went on until 6. Then the carriages came one by one, and the guests went away down the wet drive. Alice gave them back their coats, every single one. She stood at the door and handed them out in the right order, the green shawl and the cloak underneath it, the cape that smelled of pipe smoke, the umbrella that belonged to the woman who had not seen it was her.

She remembered everyone. She was good at remembering things. 11 years of medicine bottles had taught her that. Aunt Mab watched her do it from the stairs.

“You could have left,” Aunt Mab said when the last carriage had gone.

She did not shout this time. She said it quite quietly for her.

“At any point this afternoon, you could have put the lot of them on the floor and walked out of that door. Nobody would have blamed you.”

“I know,” Alice said.

“Then why didn’t you?”

Alice looked at the empty pegs in the hall.

“Because Papa always said you finish the job,” she said. “Whatever it is, even if you hate it, even if nobody thanks you. You finish it and then you decide.”

Aunt Mab nodded slowly.

“And now it’s finished,” she said. “So, what have you decided?”

Alice did not know yet. She told her aunt so. Then she went up to her room and sat on the bed in her gray dress and listened to her sister and her sister’s new husband laughing together in the best bedroom across the landing. The room that had been her father’s. She sat there for a long time.

The Duke did not leave the next morning as everyone expected. He stayed at the inn in the village. He said he had business with Julian about the northern farms. He said it would take a week, perhaps two. Nobody in the parish believed this for a moment, and everybody in the parish talked about nothing else.