“I heard you the other night in the garden. That was my husband’s carol. He sang it every Christmas Eve of our marriage, and he would have sung it last year if he had come home.”
Her voice did not shake.
“You will not sing it in his garden. You may go.”
So Rosamund went down to the scullery. She scrubbed pans in the cold stone room off the kitchen with her sleeves rolled to the elbow and her hands red to the wrist. At night she lay under the eaves and listened to the wind and thought about the hives. She thought about the gardener who was a good man but afraid of bees and who would not lift a skep to feel its weight if his life hung on it. She did not cry.
She was too angry to cry. And under the anger in a place she did not like to look at, there was something worse. She had seen the Duchess’s face under that portrait. She could not make herself hate it.
Edwin went to the walled garden that night and the night after. He told himself he was only walking as he always walked. But both times he went through the gate and up to the bench. Both times it stood empty under its thatch in the starlight, and the snow in front of it lay smooth with no footprints in it but his own.
On the third morning he went down to the stillroom himself, which no Duke of Orleton had done in living memory, and found only Martha alone at the bench with a pot of wax. Martha did not curtsy. Her knees did not allow it, she said, and she was too old to pretend otherwise for anyone. Then she told him exactly what the Duchess had done in about four sentences, and she did not soften any of them. She told him about the key and the scullery and the bees.
She told him that Rosamund Marthorp had kept those hives through every winter without losing one until the winter nobody told them the late Duke was dead. She told him that the girl had more sense than the steward and more spine than the whole of the upper servants hall put together.
“And you let it happen, Your Grace,” Martha said. “Begging your pardon. You let that poor woman run this house like a tomb because you think you owe her. You think you owe her your brother’s life.”
He stood very still.
“Do I not?”
“I couldn’t say. I wasn’t there.”
Martha set down her spoon.
“But I’ll tell you what I know, for I have lived longer than you and buried more. Shutting the doors does not bring anybody home. It only means the living sit in the dark as well as the dead.”
She looked at him with her sharp old eyes.
“That girl sang in your garden when nobody in this house would sing at all. And you came down here to the stillroom on your own, two feet looking for her. So don’t tell me you don’t know why.”
He did not tell her anything.
He went upstairs. Lucricia was in her sitting room under the portrait. Edwin stood in the doorway and looked at his brother laughing over the fire, and for a moment he could not speak. Then he did.
He said that Miss Marthorp would go back to the stillroom in the morning and back to her bees. He said it quietly, but he did not ask. Lucricia looked at him as though he had struck her.