“About time,” Martha said. “And the candles for the chapel?”

“Ask Miss Marthorp,” he said. “I will not ask her for anything myself. Not now. Tell her it is the house that wants them.”

Martha told her. She told her in the stillroom with the door shut, and then she sat down on her stool and looked at Rosamund for a long considering moment over her spectacles.

“He came down here one morning looking for you,” she said. “He went up and faced the duchess for you, which nobody in this house has dared to do in a twelvemonth. And now he is giving the whole village its Christmas back. And he won’t so much as ask you for a candle in case you think he is asking for something else.”

She sniffed.

“If you are waiting for a duke to be sensible, my girl, you will wait till spring. They are not made for it.”

“He is a duke, Martha,” Rosamund said very low. “I am a maid. There is no sense in it. There never could be.”

“Sense,” said Martha, “is what people call being afraid when they want it to sound respectable.”

And she would not say another word on the subject all afternoon.

So that evening, Rosamund carried her beeswax candles up to the chapel. She had made them in the autumn out of the summer’s wax as she made them every year, and they had lain in their box in the stillroom ever since the order came that there would be no candles. The chapel was small and very cold, with dark, old pews, and a stone floor worn smooth by generations of Orleton knees. The great White Hold Bible lay open on its lectern by the altar rail.

It was a huge old book, as heavy as a child, with clasps of worked silver that must have been worth more than everything Rosamund owned in the world. She set her candles in their holders along the rail, and lit two of them to see by. Then, because nobody was there, she went and looked at the Bible. It lay open at the front at the pages where the family wrote its names, births, marriages, deaths, in a long column of different hands and different inks going back further than she could read in that light. The last line was the newest. The ink was still black. “Hugh, fifth Duke of Orleton, died on the eve of Christmas,” with the date beside it in a hand she had seen on the library desk.

A thin line had been drawn beneath it. She stood for a while with her fingers resting on the edge of the page, not quite touching the writing. She thought of a man riding up an icy hill in the dark to bring his brother home. Then she pinched out her candles and went down, and she did not see the duchess’s lady’s maid, watching her from the shadow of the chapel door.

In the morning the Bible was gone. It was the chapel boy who found the lectern empty, and the steward who came down to the servants’ hall at breakfast with a face like a shut door. The great Bible was missing, he said, silver clasps and all, and nobody had been in the chapel the night before, but the stillroom maid. The duchess’s lady’s maid had seen her there, alone, late, with her hands on the book. Every head at the long table turned toward Rosamund.

She stood up slowly. She said that she had taken the candles up as she was asked and looked at the book and come away, and that was all. Her voice was steady. Her hands were not, so she put them behind her back.