At the inn in Market Harrow, Evelyn woke before dawn because the floorboard sounded unfamiliar. At Blackthornne Hall, she could tell from a footstep whether Edith was going to the pantry or Benedict to the front door. Here, she knew nothing of the lives moving beyond her room, and the ignorance made her both lonely and relieved. She unfolded a sheet of paper covered with figures. Her father had taught her to write numbers carefully when she was a child.

He had been a clerk for a merchant, proud of the accuracy of his books and too willing to assume that accuracy mattered to those who signed them. When he reported a false charge, his employer had dismissed him. He spent the last years of his life unable to find a similarly trusted position. Evelyn had learned that knowing the truth did not always protect the person who spoke it. 3 days before she left Blackthornne, she had compared the household inventory with bills forwarded from the estate office.

12 lengths of linen had been charged, but only five appeared in the housekeeper’s inventory. Oil was paid for twice in one month. Edith had signed for one modest delivery. Evelyn searched her own records for an oversight before approaching Gideon.

“It will be a clerical matter,” he told her, hardly looking up. “Perhaps the goods were sent to the outer storehouse.”

“Then I must adjust the household record.”

“I shall attend to it.”

The following day brought no answer. She wrote a sealed letter asking for a formal reconciliation of the quantities and payments, keeping her own figures among her private notes. The morning she gave the letter to Benedict, she imagined she had done the prudent thing. She had trusted the system as her father had once trusted it.

In the afternoon, Victor Creswell came to the service yard. She recognized the carrier’s name from the bills, but not the face. A broad man with a pale scar near his left ear, dressed in a gray traveling coat. A porter had allowed him through after seeing Gideon’s written authorization.

“You have been making inquiries,” he said when Evelyn passed the laundry entrance.

“I have asked for clarification of household expenses.”

“That is an ambitious way for a housekeeper to describe prying.”

She tried to walk past him. He stepped across her path.

“Mr. Mercer can explain anything that concerns his office,” Evelyn said. “You should speak to him.”

“I have, and now I am speaking to you. Stop examining the accounts. Leave this house. Do not tell the Duke what you suspect.”

“Move aside.”

He caught her wrist. The pressure was immediate and deliberate. She felt the bones grind against one another.

“His Grace is due to inspect the western storehouse next week,” Victor said. “A carriage takes that narrow road every morning. Wheels break, horses shy. There needn’t be any misfortune if you leave and keep your notes to yourself.”

“If you harm him…”

“If you do as you are told, no one need be harmed.”

He released her and walked away, leaving her hand aching and her mind filled with the image of Alexander’s carriage overturned in a ditch. Evelyn knew a promise from such a man was worthless. But refusing might turn a threat into action before she could convince anyone. She thought of Alexander discovering that a stranger had touched her and responding with an anger that would swallow all hope of a careful inquiry. He had never struck a servant, never punished anyone without a hearing.

Yet she had seen him turn cold and absolute when men threatened those under his protection. She feared not merely his temper, but the certainty with which powerful men sometimes acted before listening. She arranged to leave on the afternoon coach, informed Benedict that she had resigned, and wrote an address where wages and a reference could be sent. Her notes contained observations from household accounts, not stolen originals. She did not tell herself departure was wise.