“On account of a few bales of linen?”
“On account of payments that cannot be reconciled, explanations that contradict independent records, and an obligation to protect those whose wages and rents depend upon the estate.”
Gideon sank into a chair without being invited. For a moment his age showed, then he leaned forward.
“I can return the disputed money. There is no need to expose the family to public scandal. Allow me to retire. Your father would have understood.”
“My father is not here to choose. I am.”
“Then choose wisely. An inquiry will uncover more than payments. People will ask why you listen so closely to a housekeeper. They will say she shared your confidence in ways no respectable woman in her position should.”
Anger rose. Alexander kept his hands on the ledger instead of summoning footmen to remove Gideon.
“Miss Hartwell’s character is not part of this transaction. You may answer the financial discrepancies through Mr. Pembrey. You may not settle them by threatening her name.”
Gideon gave a bitter laugh.
“She has changed you.”
“That does not alter the figures,” Alexander said.
A silence followed. Gideon tried once more to recall childhood loyalty, winter hardship, favors owed, and sacrifices made. Alexander listened without pretending those years had meant nothing. Then he repeated that the records must be transferred and any wrongdoing examined by the proper authorities. Gideon rose pale with humiliation.
He had feared an angry outburst, a bargain he could exploit, or a plea for old loyalty. He had not expected the Duke to separate gratitude for the past from responsibility in the present. Samuel read through the transfer arrangements. A temporary administrator would receive current rent schedules, tenant correspondence, and payment obligations under supervision. Two tenants had repairs promised before the next rain.
The miller awaited payment for grain, and the autumn rents had to be recorded without demanding them twice. Alexander ordered the outstanding obligations listed by date so that removing Gideon would not punish those dependent upon the estate. Gideon was not locked away, assaulted, or declared guilty by private decree. He was required to surrender authority that could no longer safely remain in his hands. Samuel would present the allegations, supporting papers, and witness accounts to the local justice of the peace and follow the lawful process for any further inquiry.
Outside the study, a groom waited for feed money, and a widow needed the allowance promised after her husband’s death. Before Alexander could sign, a clerk brought news that rain had come through the roof of a tenant cottage. Gideon alone had held authority to release the repair funds. The roofer would not begin without payment. Alexander checked the previous approval, authorized the roofer’s immediate advance through the temporary arrangement Samuel had just recorded, and signed the groom’s and widow’s instructions as well.
Removing Gideon would cost him hours of work and careful scrutiny, not merely the comfort of righteous anger. By afternoon, Samuel had made the first formal approach to the magistrate. He explained that the suspected fraudulent disbursements were better documented than the claimed connection to the damaged storehouse. Evelyn’s account of Victor’s threat was recorded separately. No one suggested there was already proof of an intended killing.
The law would have to proceed on the evidence available, not on what an angry duke wished were true. Alexander went alone to the conservatory at dusk. The October flowers had begun to fade. He remembered Evelyn saying that a house was warm when its people felt heard. He could not restore Evelyn’s lost opportunity in York by command or erase the innkeeper’s notice.