“I would have protected you.”
“I was not afraid you would fail to protect me,” she said. “I was afraid of what you might become while trying.”
He looked as if she had put a hand against a wound he had concealed even from himself.
“I have never hurt you,” he said.
“No, you have been fair to me in a hundred ways. But you can make men tremble merely by turning your attention upon them. When someone tells you a person has wronged your household, you decide very quickly what must be done. And when I imagined you discovering Victor had touched me, I feared you might act before you heard the whole story.”
Alexander sat back. He remembered issuing sharp orders after the break-in, frightening an exhausted porter who had known nothing. He had apologized later, but the porter had continued to flinch when summoned. Evelyn must have noticed.
“You are right that I make decisions too quickly,” he admitted. “I cannot promise never to feel anger, but I can promise not to use it as evidence.”
She turned toward him.
“What will you do?”
“Ask my solicitor to examine the accounts. Let the proper authorities decide what action the evidence supports. I will not send men to beat Creswell or lock Mercer in a cellar.”
“Even if they are guilty?”
“Especially then.”
Silence stretched between them. The traveler folded his paper and left. Evelyn felt her shoulders loosen a fraction.
“I have copied the figures I saw,” she said. “They are from records I kept in the ordinary course of my work. I took no estate documents.”
“May Samuel see them?”
“Yes, I would rather explain them myself.”
“Then you shall.”
He paused.
“I can arrange a safer place for you to stay while this is examined.”
“I can pay for this room.”
“I did not mean…”
“I know what you meant, but please allow me to decide what help I need.”
For the first time that morning, he smiled. Not because her refusal amused him, but because he recognized the Evelyn who used to correct his household calculations without flinching.
“You are right again.”
She looked away quickly.
“I should warn you, Your Grace, that this may become a tiresome habit.”
“I remember it being so.”
He noticed her bruised wrist beside the arm of the chair. For a moment, he wanted to take her hand and promise that nothing would touch her again. Instead, he rested his own hand open on the table between them, leaving the space hers to cross or not. Evelyn glanced at it.
She did not move closer, but neither did she look away. Their eyes met. The warmth that passed between them was more dangerous than the argument, because it offered something neither was yet free to claim. Alexander rose.
“I will leave you to your day. Samuel will write to request an interview, and you may choose the time.”
“You are not going to ask me home?”
“I would like to.” He held her gaze. “But wanting something does not give me a right to demand it.”
Evelyn felt tears threaten to her annoyance. He had crossed 12 miles to ask questions that were hers to answer, and was now preparing to leave without reward.
“I did not go because I wish to hurt you,” she whispered.
“I know that now.”
“You do not know everything.”
“No,” he said, “but I shall try to deserve whatever you may choose to tell me.”
He bowed. Neither the remote gesture of a duke addressing a servant, nor the intimacy of a lover. It was simply respectful. When his carriage rolled away, Evelyn returned to her room and took out her notes. For the first time since Victor had seized her wrist, she could imagine telling the truth without surrendering herself to someone else’s protection.