Gideon Mercer received Alexander in the estate office with the familiar courtesy of a man certain that years of loyal service would outweigh a few questionable numbers. Through the open door came the scratch of a clerk’s pen and the muted calls of stable hands at work. This was not a dungeon or a secret chamber. It was the ordinary center of the administration on which hundreds of people depended.

“I have spoken to Miss Hartwell,” Alexander said.

Gideon set down his pen.

“Then you will have heard a great deal of speculation.”

“I heard her describe a threat made by Creswell. He knew the intended route of my inspection next week.”

“The route was hardly secret. A duke cannot keep his movements hidden from every tenant and carrier.”

“That is true. It is also not an answer to why a carrier threatened my former housekeeper.”

“Former housekeeper,” Gideon repeated, emphasizing the first word. “I am relieved she has taken another position. She was beginning to forget the boundaries of her office.”

Alexander looked at the books spread upon the table.

“Her office was to know what the house received. She reports that the house received less than we paid for.”

“Then some carrier has failed us. I will see the man dismissed.”

“You recommended Creswell for renewed work last year.”

“I recommended a carrier available at a reasonable price.”

“You authorized payments before goods were received. Samuel will examine the original receipts.”

Gideon’s eyebrows rose.

“You have brought a solicitor into the household over lamp oil?”

“Over the use of estate funds.”

A thin flush entered the older man’s face.

“I walked beside your father when this land was threatened by creditors. I negotiated rents when you were still at school. No man has guarded this family more faithfully.”

“I know what you did for my father.”

“And now a woman who has been in the house 2 years persuades you to question me?”

Alexander remained seated.

“It is the figures that persuade me to question you.”

“Do you not see how it will look? A duke takes the word of his housekeeper above the steward who served his father. People will decide she has secured your attention by means that have nothing to do with accounts.”

The suggestion struck with precisely the cruelty intended. Evelyn had already paid for her honesty with bruises and flight. Gideon was offering to make her pay with her name.

“Speak of the books,” Alexander said, “not of her character.”

“I speak of yours. A household must have order.”

“Order does not require a frightened woman to be silent.”

Gideon leaned back.

“One day you may regret believing that distinction is so simple.”

Alexander stood.

“Please have the original vouchers ready for Mr. Pembrey by tomorrow morning.”

“I will give him what the records contain.”

“Give him all they contain.”

On the way out, Alexander passed the room where his father had once sat with Gideon over estate maps. He remembered his father’s great hand resting on the steward’s shoulder, the easy faith of men who had endured difficult years together. Alexander did not despise that faith.

He grieved to discover it could no longer answer the present question. Samuel met him that evening with a troubling comparison. A carrier’s charge approved just before the Western Storehouse break-in, a shortage in the receiving book, and a signature too blurred to identify.

“Enough to question, not to condemn,” Samuel said. “I shall speak to the porter and seek the carrier’s record.”

Alexander agreed. Gideon would have every opportunity to answer. He would not have the opportunity to make the papers disappear. On his desk lay a note Evelyn had sent in answer to Samuel’s formal request. She was willing to meet and explain her figures.