“The allegation about access to documents may be examined,” he said. “You had ordinary access to the household records you have described. No one has shown me evidence that you removed the steward’s papers.”

“What of the other allegation?” she asked, color rising in her face.

“An insinuation about your personal conduct is not evidence. I can assist in preparing an accurate account of your duties, and Mr. Shaw and Mrs. Fenwick can confirm them.”

“I would like to write the reply myself.”

“Then you shall. I will tell you which statements can be supported by documents.”

Alexander came that afternoon after Samuel informed him of the employment letter. Evelyn had expected anger. His face was strained, but his first question was whether she wished him to stay.

“Yes,” she said. “There are things we ought to discuss.”

He sat beside the window, keeping an appropriate distance. She showed him the letter from York, watching him read the sentence about her propriety. A flush rose along his cheekbones.

“I can write to the family myself,” he said. “I can tell them I know your character.”

“And will they believe me honest or believe me protected by a duke whose favor I have somehow obtained?”

He looked at the paper in his hand.

“You are right. What would you prefer?”

“I have already asked them to explain the accusation. I want a reference founded on the work I did signed by those who witnessed it. I will not have you frighten people into praising me.”

“I would never wish them to praise you falsely.”

“You might wish them to fear contradicting you. That is not quite the same thing.”

Alexander bowed his head, accepting the distinction.

“Then I shall provide a truthful statement, and you may decide whether it is used.”

The simple offer nearly undid her. She had spent days imagining that his protection would engulf her until there was no Evelyn left apart from the Duke of Ashkam’s kindness. Instead, he placed a choice in her hands.

“I am frightened,” she admitted. “I thought I could leave Blackthornne and be judged on my work elsewhere. Now, even that may be taken from me.”

“I cannot promise the world will be fair,” he answered. “I can promise I will not join it in refusing to hear you.”

She looked at him then really looked and saw not a powerful man offering to arrange her future but a tired one struggling to stand beside her without stepping in front.

“Thank you,” she said. “That is more help than you know.”

Samuel’s messenger arrived near dusk with word that the estate papers were ready for presentation to a local justice. Alexander rose to leave. Evelyn wished him courage, and his expression softened with an astonishment she could not quite bear to examine. She was still afraid of the coming days, but she had answered the letter from York in her own hand. Whatever strangers might decide about her, she had not surrendered her voice.

On the seventh morning, Gideon Mercer entered Alexander’s study, expecting an argument, and found Samuel Pembrey beside a neatly arranged inventory of documents. Two clerks waited in the adjoining office, ready to record the transfer of daily responsibilities. The arrangement made Gideon uneasy. A furious duke would have been easier to manage than a careful one.

“You are relieved of responsibility for estate disbursements while these irregularities are examined,” Alexander said. “Mr. Pembrey will supervise the transfer of the records and arrange temporary management. Your contractual entitlements will be dealt with lawfully.”

“You cannot seriously intend this?”

“I do.”