A noble acquaintance wrote that if Alexander proceeded with his intention to marry his former housekeeper, Evelyn would not be received at that family’s gatherings. The wording was courteous enough to make its cruelty worse. Evelyn set the letter on the table. She had expected resistance, but seeing it expressed in ink gave it a weight rumor lacked.
“Do you regret this?” she asked.
Alexander did not pretend the letter meant nothing.
“I regret that people who know almost nothing of you think they may decide your worth. I regret that you will have to endure judgments you never invited.”
“That is not quite my question.”
“No,” he said softly. “I do not regret loving you, but I cannot promise that society will welcome you, nor that you will never feel alone among people I have known all my life.”
“Would you expect me to spend every day becoming the perfect duchess to please them?”
“I would hope you learn what is useful for the life you choose. I will learn what I have neglected about yours. Neither of us should live merely to silence other people.”
She looked toward the window where carts moved through the square and a young girl hurried beside her mother carrying bread. Ordinary lives continued beyond the judgments of drawing rooms. Evelyn had spent most of her years earning the right to support herself and speak her mind. Marriage must not require her to lay those things aside.
“I cannot be grateful for a title as though it were salvation,” she said. “I was a person worthy of respect before you knew you loved me.”
“I know. I am ashamed that it took me so long to understand how often I made you prove it.”
“And I will not ask you to abandon your duties because certain people are cruel.”
“Then we shall face those duties together without pretending our lives will be simple.”
Alexander took a small step closer.
“Evelyn Hartwell, will you marry me? Not to repay any service, not to escape anyone’s judgment and not because a duke has asked you. Only if you wish to make a life with the man standing before you.”
Her answer was quiet.
“Yes, Alexander, I do.”
They did not announce the news with a ball. First, they informed the people who had given Evelyn honest friendship, including Edith and Benedict. Then they made arrangements to share their intention with the wider circle that would inevitably have opinions. Some letters brought warm wishes. Others did not.
Alexander read them without allowing either kind to decide his happiness. A few days later, Evelyn visited Blackthornne Hall with him before they went on to Market Harrow to call upon acquaintances. Her traveling trunk waited near the front entrance, secured for the short journey. The sight brought them both to a halt. She remembered standing in almost the same place, trembling beneath her cloak, certain that the only way to keep him safe was to disappear.
“I have something,” she said.
From her bag, she took the wooden box Alexander had given her. She had carried it through 3 weeks of courtship without opening it, wanting to decide what the contents meant only after she had decided about her future. Inside lay the little brass key to the housekeeper’s workroom, its teeth worn smooth by years of use. She turned it in her fingers.
Once it had meant responsibility for linen, stores, and the comfort of a household that belonged to someone else. The work had been honorable. She would not pretend otherwise. She would not forget it.
“Would you like me to put it away?” Alexander asked.
“No.”
She returned the key to the box and closed the lid.
“I should like to keep it, not because it opens a door I must tend, but because I remember the woman who carried it.”
“I hope you will never feel you have to surrender her.”
“I do not intend to.”
He offered his arm. She took it and together they crossed the threshold. Benedict opened the outer door, smiling only a little.
The afternoon light fell on the gravel and the waiting carriage. Once she had crossed this threshold alone, carrying everything she owned. Now she stepped into the afternoon beside Alexander, her hand resting freely on his arm as the carriage waited.