Lady Beatrice looked at her for a long time.

“You may go, Miss Elwood.”

She turned her face to the fire. When the door had closed, she did not move for several minutes. She was sixty-eight. She had married at seventeen a man of fifty-one because her father had lost the London house at cards in 1789 and the family had needed his money urgently. She had not loved him. She had not expected to. He had been dull and not cruel, and he had died in his bed, and she had been safe every day since.

She had seen her brother’s family come within an inch of losing Rexley once, and she knew exactly what a house looked like from the inside when the bailiffs came. Nobody else in the house remembered. She did. There was a letter in her writing desk drawer that she had never answered. It was from Louisa, dated a week before she died. It began with an endearment nobody else in the world had ever used for her, and it asked her gently to help Aubrey understand that the school was not an amusement.

She had meant to answer it. She had meant to answer it the following week. She sat in her chair with her hands folded and her back straight and thought that safety was a better bargain than love, because she had made it and was still here. She told herself that with great certainty. She did not take the letter out.

The duke wrote to Mr. Nathaniel Crowe at the bank in Shrewsbury on the ninth of February, asking to see his sister’s deed of endowment. He told Esme so at breakfast with a bitter sort of satisfaction, like a man telling you he had at last had a tooth pulled. The bank’s reply ought to have come within a week. It did not. On the eighteenth, Mr. Thurlow drove over from Market Rexley and stayed to dinner. He was very agreeable through the soup.

Afterwards, in the library with the door closed and only the duke and Lady Beatrice present, he said he feared he had something difficult to say. Esme was not in the room. She heard it afterwards from the duke in pieces, but she always thought she could see it as clearly as if she had stood in the doorway: the low, soft voice, the hands opened regretfully, the way he never said anything unkind.

Mr. Crowe had replied. Mr. Thurlow knew that for a fact because Mr. Crowe had mentioned it to him in Shrewsbury. The letter had been sent to Rexley on the thirteenth. Since Miss Elwood had taken over the household arrangements, all correspondence passed through the housekeeper’s room for sorting. He was not accusing anybody. He only wondered. He also wondered whether His Grace had looked in Miss Kesteven’s writing desk lately, because he had heard there was a letter there referring to the Reverend Elwood, a letter which, if made public, might do a great deal of harm to that excellent clergyman.

The duke went to the desk that evening. The compartment at the back was empty. At seven the following morning, a maid sweeping the housekeeper’s room found in the ashes the corner of a letter, the seal of Crowe’s Bank, Shrewsbury, half melted, three lines in a clerk’s hand browned at the edges: “Your Grace’s request concerning Miss Kesteven’s deed of endowment…” He sent for her at nine.

She came into the library, saw what was on the desk, understood everything at once, and could say nothing.

“Did you know before you came to this house that your father held my sister’s account book?”

“No, Your Grace.”

“Have you been to him about it?”

“Yes.”

“What did he say?”

That was all of it. The whole thing in four words. She could tell him that her father had admitted it, that he had the book, that he had refused to show it, that he had said some things were better left in a drawer. She could tell him all of that, and it would be true, and it would be the end of Thomas Elwood.

“I cannot tell you that, Your Grace.”