He did very well for the first quarter of an hour. He spoke of a dying woman’s wishes imperfectly expressed. He spoke of a misunderstanding between friends. He spoke sadly of the Reverend Elwood, whose signature was as clear upon the authority as his own. Then the older magistrate untied the ribbon and began reading the first letter aloud, and Horace Thurlow heard his own daughter’s handwriting read back to him in that cold room, and something went out of him.

“My wife’s brother was in a bad way,” he said suddenly, to nobody. “The company was failing. He owed four thousand pounds in Shrewsbury. He would have gone to the Fleet. I meant to put it back. I paid the school for the first year out of it so nobody would ask, and then there was nothing left to pay it with. So I printed the notice.”

He looked down the table at the duke.

“I did not think anybody would read it, Your Grace. Nobody ever read anything. You signed every paper I put before you for three years.”

“I know,” said the Duke of Rexley. “That is my part. I have come to own it. You may own yours now.”

The magistrates committed Horace Thurlow for trial at Shrewsbury for forgery and fraud, and they did it inside an hour. His remaining property was secured for the benefit of the school. Perhaps fourteen hundred pounds of the two thousand could be recovered, Mr. Crowe thought carefully. The duke learned that day, as Esme had warned him, that he could not simply declare the endowment restored. It was a trust. Only the Court of Chancery could appoint new trustees, and Chancery did nothing quickly.

So he did the one thing a duke could legally do. He bound the estate in writing to pay the school eighty pounds a year out of its rents until the court had acted, with the payments to be receipted every quarter by Miss Mercer in her own hand.

Then the Reverend Thomas Elwood stood up. Nobody had asked him to. He had sat at the end of the table all morning, small in his old black coat, and said nothing. Now he stood with his hands shaking and put them flat on the table to stop them.

“I witnessed that authority,” he said. “I knew within a day it was a lie. I have been silent for two years and eleven months out of fear for my living and my name. Those girls have had no slates and no fire because I was afraid. I shall say that in my own church on Sunday before all my congregation. I ask for nothing.”

The magistrates took his statement as a witness. Mr. Crowe told them plainly that the clergyman had been deceived as the bank had been deceived. They let him go home. The following Sunday he stood in his pulpit at Saltley and said it all again, word for word, to forty boys and their mothers. Esme sat in the front pew and watched him do it. It was the bravest thing she had ever seen him do. It was three years late. Both things were true, and she found she could hold them both.

The next morning, the duke went to the girls’ school and told the mothers himself. He stood in the stone room in front of the benches with his hat in his hand, and he did not make a speech. He told them what had been taken, by whom, and for how long, and he made the failure to notice it his own. When he finished, nobody spoke. Then a thin, tired woman in a widow’s bonnet stood at the back. It was Mrs. Hephzibah Rudd, Lettice’s mother, who had never spoken to a duke in her life.

“It is not your coal we want, Your Grace, nor your favours, nor your being sorry. We are grateful for them. But coal can be stopped. We want it written down as Miss Kesteven wrote it, so nobody can take it away from our daughters again. Not you, nor anybody else.”

“It will be written down, Mrs. Rudd,” the duke said. “I give you my word, and more than my word alone.”