He stopped.

“And there is another thing. A girl who can read can read a hiring paper. She can read what she is putting her mark to. Your sister used to say that every girl who learned her letters here was one more girl in this county who could not easily be cheated. This is not charity, Your Grace. It is armour.”

Then Miss Mercer brought out the letters. She had all of them. Louisa Kesteven’s letters, in a clear, quick, slanting hand, promising the school eighty pounds a year from an endowment of two thousand pounds held in the funds in her name, to be paid for ever. The first payments had come like clockwork, every quarter for three years. Then Louisa had died of fever in March 1821. After that came late payments, then short ones. Then, in January 1822, a printed notice from Mr. Thurlow’s office regretting that the endowment had been exhausted and that the school must henceforth depend on private generosity.

The duke read the notice. He was silent for a long time.

“Mr. Thurlow told me my sister had arranged to spend the capital. He said it was her own wish. She wanted it used to do the most good in the shortest time.”

Esme did a sum. She did not mean to say it aloud. It came out anyway.

“Two thousand pounds in the three per cents makes sixty pounds a year, Your Grace. She promised eighty. That means she intended to add to it every year herself from her private allowance. A woman does not do that with money she means to spend away. She does it with money she means to last.”

Miss Mercer looked at her. It was the face of somebody who had been saying that silently for two years and had suddenly heard another person say it. In the carriage home, they quarrelled. It began quietly. She asked who had looked at the endowment papers since his sister died. He said Mr. Thurlow. She asked who else. He said nobody else had needed to. She asked why not.

“Because he is my solicitor, Miss Elwood. He has been this family’s solicitor for twenty years. I pay him to read papers instead of me.”

“You left another man to mind your sister’s school.”

“I left a professional to do the work he is paid to do.”

She should have stopped there. She knew she should. But she had sat in that stone room and watched twenty-two girls stand up for him, and she could not.

“Your Grace, you left him to do it because it was easier than reading her handwriting.”

The carriage went on through the dark. He turned his face towards the window. He said nothing for the rest of the journey, and when they arrived he got out and went into the house without a word to her. She stood in the hall on the black and white stone where she had stood six weeks before with her trunk, and thought it very likely she had just lost her place.

At eleven that night there was a knock at the housekeeper’s room. It was the duke. He had a candle in one hand and a small key in the other.

“You were right. In the carriage. I want you there when I do this. I do not think I can do it alone.”

Louisa Kesteven’s writing desk stood in a little sitting room in the west wing that nobody had entered since the spring of 1821. It was a pretty walnut thing with brass corners. There was still a pen in the tray, dried black. The duke stood in front of it for a long time with the key in his hand.

“I was in London when she died,” he said. “We had quarrelled. She wanted me to settle the school legally upon trustees so it would not depend on her. I said it was a woman’s amusement, and I had a roof falling in and my father’s debts to pay. I said considerably more than that. I went to London the next morning. Eleven days later they wrote that she had a fever. I was on the road when she died.”