Her hands were shaking. She let them. Then she looked up at Georgiana’s face in the lamplight, and she saw quite clearly the face she had painted on the lid of the box, the eyes made larger, the neck made longer, the mouth made a little less decided, a face arranged to be looked at by a woman who loved nothing so well as being looked at. Matilda had spent the whole of the autumn studying that face. She knew it better than its owner did.

“No,” she said.

Georgiana’s smile stayed exactly where it was.

“I beg your pardon.”

“I won’t paint out my mark,” said Matilda.

Her voice was low and quite steady.

“Now that box is the best work I have ever done. It took me the whole autumn. You may have it on the terms we agreed as my work with my mark in the corner. Or you may not have it at all. And I won’t take my chaise in the morning.”

She set down the brush.

“If His Grace wants me to go, he’ll tell me so himself to my face. He’s that kind of man. I’ve watched him all week. He says things to your face, or he doesn’t say them. He doesn’t send messengers in blue silk.”

“You think he’ll marry you?”

Georgiana’s voice had gone very soft.

“A woman with varnish under her nails.”

“I think,” said Matilda. “That’s between him and me, Miss Lyall. Not you.”

She looked at her a moment longer. Then she said the thing she had not meant to say, and said it quietly, without any cruelty at all.

“I painted you exactly as you asked me to. I have looked at your face every day for months. And I’ll tell you what I learned from it. You would always rather be looked at than be seen. I’d rather be seen. That’s the whole difference between us. It isn’t the gown.”

For a moment, Georgiana did not move. Her lovely face went perfectly blank, the way a looking glass goes blank when the candle is taken away. Then she turned and went out of the still room without a word, and did not close the door behind her. Matilda heard her silk go whispering away down the passage. She sat on in the lamplight with her hands flat on the table and listened to the house go quiet.

The box sat under its muslin. Nobody came back for it. The Duke found her there. He had seen the blue silk go past the library door and he had seen Miss Lyall’s face.

He came and stood in the still room doorway and looked at Matilda sitting with her hands flat on the table and he did not ask what had happened. He came in and sat down across from her and waited. After a while she told him all of it. The bargain, the mark, the school at Bath, the strays of Christmas.

“My aunt asked me for the school,” he said when she had done. “I told her no. I told her Rose stays in her mother’s house and so do you. For as long as you choose.”