He looked at his hands.
“I find I’ve kept the habit, and I don’t know how to break it.”
He did not say who it was, and Matilda did not ask. She had lived long enough among other people’s griefs to know that the name was the last thing a person gives you, not the first.
“Rose’s mother taught me everything I know,” she said instead quietly. “And her father, too. When they died, I didn’t know how to go into the workshop in the mornings. Everything was in its place, their brushes, their aprons on the hook. For weeks, I went in by the back door so I wouldn’t have to see the aprons.”
She turned her cup.
“Then Rose took them down one morning and put them on both of them at once and came to breakfast looking like a parcel, and I laughed, which I hadn’t done in a month. After that, I could go in by the front door again.”
He was looking at her, and she did not know what he saw. Then far down the hill and across the snow, faint and clear, the bells of the village church began to ring for midnight. They both turned their heads toward the window. The sound came and went on the wind and came again.
Christmas had arrived at Pinewend, whether it was wanted there or not. The Duke listened until the last bell stopped, and then he looked back at her across the table, and his mouth moved again on that same side. This time it was very nearly a smile.
“Happy Christmas, Miss Carton,” he said.
It sounded, she thought, like something he had not said aloud in a very long time.
“Happy Christmas, Your Grace,” said Matilda.
When she reached for the teapot, his hand was already there, and for a moment they both held it, his fingers over hers, warm from the range. Neither of them said anything about it. He let go first, and she poured the tea. Ralph came back up the hill at first light on Christmas morning as he had always meant to. He came on foot through snow to his knees with a basket on his arm and his good coat buttoned to the chin, muttering about dukes and mice. He let himself in by the kitchen door, and there he stopped because the range was lit and the kettle was singing, and a young woman he had never seen in his life was standing at his master’s kitchen table with her sleeves rolled up, cutting bread.
“Good morning,” said Matilda. “You must be Ralph. His Grace said you would come, though he said you shouldn’t. And there’s tea in the pot.”
Ralph was a thin, upright old man with white hair and a long, sad face that had spent half a century keeping its opinions to itself. He set down his basket and looked at the bread, the tea, and the young woman. Then he looked at the window, where the Duke could be seen in the stable yard in his shirt sleeves, breaking the ice on the horse trough with the back of a spade. Ralph had not seen the Duke in his shirt sleeves since he was a boy. He took off his hat very slowly.