He was silent for a long time. Then he spoke in a voice she had not heard from him before.

“I should like you to stay. Whatever Lord Henry says. My mother needs you here.”

He hesitated, and the next word seemed to cost him something.

“Please.”

As she went up to her narrow room under the eaves, she thought that this was the first time the Duke of Heather had asked her for anything. It could not, she thought, be something he did very often.

On Friday morning, the Duke walked with Lady Lavinia in the frost-covered shrubbery because her father had arranged it, and because he owed her an honest answer. She gave him one first.

“I will not pretend,” she said, her breath white in the cold air. “My father wants your title for his grandsons. I want something else. I want a house where no one shouts at breakfast, a library of my own, and a husband who will not require me to love him more than he can love me in return. I thought you might give me those things, Your Grace. I thought we might suit one another very well, and neither of us need pretend to anything we did not feel.”

He walked beside her in silence. He understood that this was precisely the marriage he had always said was the only kind worth having, if one must have a marriage at all. No hunger, no disappointed hopes. A sensible arrangement between two people who would never wound one another because they would never come close enough. A week earlier, he might even have considered it. Now it felt cold in every part of him.

Lady Lavinia watched his face. She was an intelligent woman, and she had spent her life observing people’s faces.

“Last night,” she said gently, “when your mother’s maid left the drawing room, you looked toward the door three times.”

She smiled a little, without resentment.

“My father will want an answer before Sunday. I shall tell him to wait. But I will not marry a man who looks at a door like that, Your Grace. I have watched my mother do it.”

That afternoon, Damaris went down to the stillroom for the Dowager’s lavender water. She stopped outside because she heard Mr. Griggs speaking in a tone she had never heard him use.

“Five packets, Beatrice. Five of them, that autumn of nineteen. Posted from London in His late Grace’s own hand and addressed to Mr. Quenby. I carried them up to the estate office myself. Thick packets, not accounts. A man cannot write that much about barley.”

“And Mr. Quenby took them to Lady Griselda, as was proper.”

Mrs. Vale’s voice was low and hard.

“What happened after that was no concern of yours, Thomas, and no concern of mine. It was Her Ladyship’s business.”

“They were not hers to keep.”

“If Her Grace were to learn of it after all these years, it would break her heart. Do you understand me? It would kill her.”

A sharp breath followed.

“Let the dead rest. I made a promise, and I shall keep it.”

Damaris stood motionless in the dark passage with the empty bottle in her hand. Then she heard footsteps and turned quickly back the way she had come before either of them could see her. Five packets from London, in the autumn of 1819, the year the late Duke went to town to see his physicians and never returned. Addressed to her father.

“There is a house where I left a debt I cannot pay.”

Mr. Charles Pembrook arrived at four in the rain to attend to the Dowager’s quarter-day business. He was a thin, dry, careful man of about sixty, with spectacles and a voice like pages being turned, and had been solicitor to the Heathersett family for thirty years. Damaris waited in the cold passage outside the library. When he came out, she stepped into his path.