They argued about it for an hour, until she brought out a charter from the Reverend Brooks’s parish chest and proved him mistaken. He laughed aloud. In the next room, Mr. Brooks put down his sermon and smiled.
That same week, without telling her beforehand, the Duke wrote to Mr. Pembrook. He said that Miss Quenby was the finest reader of old documents he had ever encountered, and that any solicitor’s office in England would be fortunate to have her. He offered the recommendation without any condition attached. Mr. Pembrook, who had practiced law for forty years and was seldom surprised, read the letter twice and then showed it to her.
At Heather Hall, the Duke unlocked the east wing. He did it with his mother. On a gray December morning, they went together through his father’s rooms and opened the shutters that had been closed for four years. In the late Duke’s desk they found the books Adelaide had read during the first year of their marriage, the very books he had left on the table for her without a word. He had kept them all. On the flyleaf of each, in that strong, upright hand, he had written the date she finished it.
The older woman sat on her husband’s bed with them in her lap, laughing and crying together. Then her son sat beside her, took her hand, and asked her what his father had been like at three and twenty. She told him. It took all afternoon.
On the first evening of the new year, with snow lying thick over the park, the Duke of Heather walked across the fields to the rectory again. He had a letter in his pocket. He had written it eleven times. He did not post it, leave it on a table, or give it to a servant to carry. He knocked at the parlor door. When Damaris looked up from her papers, he crossed the room and put it into her hands himself.
“I will not do what my father did,” he said, “send my heart through other people’s hands and then wait in silence for an answer. Read it. I shall stand here while you do. And whatever you wish to ask me about any line of it, ask. I will answer you aloud.”
She broke the seal. It was not long. It said nothing of his house, his mother, his sister, or the running of his household. It said that she read the crossed-out lines of a letter before reading the rest, and that he had begun trying to do the same with people. It said that she was wrong about almost nothing, but right about horses, and that he would be honored to teach her not to fear them if she wished, and would not mind at all if she did not.
It said that chapter four was better than chapter two. It said that if she went to Norwich in the spring, he would ride there every Sunday and be glad of it. If she wished to marry before that, or afterward, or never, the choice was hers, and he would not decide it for her. It said that he loved her not for what she had brought to his family, but for the way she had stood in his library with nothing but her word and refused to retreat.
At the bottom, after a line written and crossed out so heavily that even she could not read it, he had written simply:
“I am asking you. Will you have me?”
She read to the end. Then she looked for a long time at the crossed-out line before looking up at him.