The Duke’s voice shook. He steadied it and went on. The third letter begged. There was no pride left in it.
“Write me one line. Only one. If you tell me to come home, I shall come, physicians or no physicians. If you tell me to stay away, I shall stay away and trouble you no more. Only do not leave me in this silence. I have lived in it too long.”
The fourth was only a few lines, in handwriting that had begun to tremble.
“Still nothing. I shall write once more.”
The fifth, dated January 2, 1820, a week before he died, was so short that the Duke had finished it before he could stop himself.
“Then I have my answer, and I shall not ask again. I do not blame you. I only wish I had spoken twenty years ago, when it might still have mattered. God bless you, my dearest. You were the best thing in my life, and I never told you. F.”
The room was completely silent. Sebastian stood beside the fire with the letter in his hand, his face wet, and did not wipe it. Lady Catherine was sobbing. The Dowager had not moved. Then, very slowly, she reached into the pocket of her gown, drew out the folded page worn soft along its creases, and gave it to her son.
“Here is my answer,” she said. “I wrote it that November. I never sent it because I was waiting for him to write first. Read that too. Then you shall have both halves.”
He read it. When he had finished, he laid the two letters on the table side by side: his father and his mother, two answers to the same question, written a hundred miles apart, each waiting for the other to speak. He knelt beside his mother’s chair.
“I made your marriage the reason for my life,” he said, his voice breaking. “All my life, I made it my reason never to need anyone. And I never asked whether it was the reason you would have chosen. I simply decided what you had lived through and built my whole life upon it. I did to you exactly what he did to you. Mother, forgive me.”
The Dowager laid her hand on her son’s head, something she had not done since he was a child. For a long time she said nothing. Then she looked across the room at the young woman in the gray pelisse, sitting straight on the chair by the door, with tears running quietly down her face.
“Miss Quenby, your father would not burn them.”
“No, Your Grace.”
“If he had done as he was told, I should never have had them. Not one line.”
The Dowager’s voice was very quiet.
“He made a great wrong that he could not undo, and he would not make it worse. I think that is as far as most of us ever get.”
She held out her hand.
“Come here, child. Come to me.”
That afternoon, before the Dunstables’ carriage was brought round, the Duke went to Lord Henry Dunstable and told him the truth: he would not offer for his daughter, either before Christmas or afterward, and the fault was entirely his. Lord Henry turned purple. He said a great many things about secretaries’ daughters and the decline of great houses. He had begun to say a great many more when his daughter put her hand on his arm.
“Papa. That will do.”
Her quiet voice stopped him as nothing else could have done. Lady Lavinia turned to the Duke and held out her hand, as one gentleman might to another.