“Why?” she asked.
He had not expected that question.
“Because this house has been alive since you came. Because my mother laughs. Because Catherine sings on the stairs. Because I cannot imagine these rooms without you. Because, God help me, a week ago I said I would never marry, and I find I was wrong about everything.”
“Those are all very good reasons,” Damaris said gently. “And every one concerns your house.”
He was silent.
“Tell me one thing about me, Your Grace. One thing that has nothing to do with your mother, or your sister, or the household running, or quieter dinners.”
“You are brave.”
“Brave in the service of your family.”
She shook her head slowly.
“What do I want? What did I mean to do with my life before Mr. Pembrook’s letter came? What do I love?”
“I do not know.”
“In seven days, you have not asked me a single question about myself. You have decided what I must feel without asking what I feel, which is what you have blamed your parents for all your life. And this morning, when you had only my word, you sent me away.”
He took it as a man takes a blow he knows he has earned.
“I am not refusing you,” she said, her voice trembling for the first time. “Please understand that. I am telling you that I will not be kept like a medicine in a cabinet, to be brought out on days when the house is cold. You want the peace I have brought. I do not yet know whether you want me. And I do not think you know either. Ask me again when you do.”
The Reverend Brooks’s gig came round the corner, its lamps swaying in the dark. She curtsied to him, very properly, as a maid curtsies to a duke. Then she stepped into the cold, and the door closed behind her. The Duke of Heather stood alone in his great hall, and for the first time in his life understood how his father had felt upon the stairs.
They gathered in the Dowager’s drawing room at ten the next morning: the Dowager beside the window, Lady Catherine on a stool at her feet holding her hand, the Duke by the fire, and Damaris, brought over from the rectory in her gray pelisse, sitting on a chair near the door. The Dowager untied the black tape herself. Her hands were perfectly steady. Then she held out the five letters, not to her daughter or to her maid, but to her son.
“Read them aloud, Sebastian,” she said. “In your own voice. You have hated him for twenty years. Now you shall hear him.”
He stared at her. Then he took them. The first was long, careful, and very formal, as though the writer had copied it many times.
“Madam,” it began, “my mother told me that on the morning of our wedding you wept and begged to be released from the match, and that you married me only because your family would accept nothing else. I have never asked whether this was true. I have feared the answer for twenty years. I ask you now because the physicians tell me I may not have another twenty. Was it true?”
The second was shorter, and its formality had begun to give way.
“You have not answered. Perhaps that is my answer. But I find I cannot leave it so. I loved you from the first week. I have loved you every day, at breakfast, upon the stairs, and in the margins of the letters I wrote to Hughes, where I asked after you because I did not dare ask you myself. I thought I was sparing you a husband you did not want. I have been so civil to you, Adelaide, that we have become strangers.”