“No, Your Grace. I opened it this morning with Her Grace beside me, in daylight, after she gave me permission. It was already empty. Ask her.”

“My mother will not see me.”

“Then I am very sorry. But I can only tell you the truth. Someone in this house went to that cabinet at two this morning. I know it was opened recently because the panel was unlocked. It could not have opened as it did if it had remained shut since Lady Griselda’s time.”

She took a breath.

“I will not name someone I did not see. I will not do to another person what Lord Henry did to my father.”

“Then I have only your word.”

“Yes, Your Grace. Only my word.”

She met his eyes.

“You have had it all week. It has not changed.”

For a long moment neither spoke. She watched him struggle: the old, cold, carefully practiced habit of distance, of shutting a door before anything could come through it, fighting something else that had entered him this week and would not leave. The old habit won. She saw it win.

“You will go to the rectory today,” he said in a voice like ice. “Mr. Brooks will give you lodging until this can be settled. I will not have my mother distressed further.”

Damaris curtsied. She did not argue. She was turning toward the door when it opened without a knock, and Miss Jemima Bell came in, still wearing her traveling cloak, mud to her ankles.

“Forgive me, Your Grace.”

She was breathless.

“I came by the night coach. My mother is better, thank God and Miss Quenby. I entered the house by the garden door at two this morning, and I saw Mrs. Vale in the south passage with a candle and a jug, going into the small drawing room. I thought nothing of it then. I will swear to it on any book you please.”

Behind her, in a spotless white apron and looking terrified, stood little Mary Collins.

“Your Grace, please come. Mrs. Vale has built up the stillroom fire something dreadful, and locked herself in, and she is crying, which she has never done in her life.”

Damaris did not wait to be dismissed. She ran. The stillroom door was locked. Mr. Griggs came quickly behind her with the household keys, opened it himself, and stood aside. Within, in the heat and the smell of dried herbs, Mrs. Beatrice Vale knelt before a blazing fire with a thick bundle of letters on her lap, tied with another length of black tape. She held one letter toward the flames. She had been holding it there a long time. Her arm was shaking.

Damaris did not snatch at it. She went in slowly and knelt on the stone floor a little way away, as though the older woman were a creature that might suddenly bolt.

“You loved her,” Damaris said softly. “Lady Griselda. You served her for thirty years. You still wear her letter at your throat.”

Mrs. Vale did not turn.

“At the end she made you promise to keep that panel shut. And you have, for four years.”

Damaris’s voice did not rise.

“But I do not think you are burning those letters to keep faith with her, Mrs. Vale. I think you are burning them so that no one in this house need know what your lady did, and so that you need not stand in the room and watch Her Grace read what she lost.”

The housekeeper’s shoulders collapsed as though something had struck her between them. When she spoke, it was in a voice no one at Heather Hall had ever heard her use.