Then, because she was a decent woman, she slipped something into Avis’s hand at the door.

“Take this, and do not argue with me on my own staircase.”

Avis carried a traveling bag, a clean collar, her father’s songbook wrapped in oilcloth, and four shillings and a penny. It was the carrier who told her about Coldmarten. He said it as men say things to fill the time. The Duke’s estate, beyond Rothbury, under the hills. They had had a governess for the little lady, but she had left at Michaelmas. Apparently she could not bear the silence. No one spoke above a whisper in that house since they buried the late Duke and Duchess.

He set her down at Thropton Bridge. She walked the last six kilometers. Sleet stung down from the Cheviots, and she went on with her head lowered and her bag against her chest, forbidding herself to think what she would do if this door closed too. There was nothing beyond that door. She knew it. She had counted her shillings.

It was quite dark when she rounded the last bend and saw Coldmarten Hall on its rise above the river: a long gray house, almost unlit, like a house that had been told to wait and had forgotten what for. She went to the kitchen door, because that was where a woman without a character went. The housekeeper who opened it was tall and thin, with keys at her waist and a face that had been closed for years. She listened to Avis on the doorstep in the sleet. At last she asked the only question that mattered.

“And who will speak for you?”

“No one, ma’am.”

“Then I regret your journey.”

Mrs. Elsdon began to close the door. Behind her in the passage, a second woman had appeared: gray-haired, very straight, dressed in black silk with a lace cap and carrying an ebony cane she did not seem to need. Lady Griselda Heddon, the Duke’s aunt, had governed Coldmarten through two years of mourning. She looked at the soaked young woman on the threshold like a magistrate examining a petition.

“Now,” she said, “I know that name. You are the Tyndall woman.”

“I was in Lord Tyndall’s service, my lady.”

“You helped his daughter escape through a window.”

Lady Griselda said it without animosity.

“We have a child in this house who lost her mother less than two years ago. You will understand why I do not wish her to be educated by a woman of that reputation.”

Avis was ready to curtsy and go. Then she discovered that she was not ready after all.

“I did not help her through a window, my lady. I unlocked a door. It was a door that should never have been locked.”

The passage became silent. Somewhere a clock ticked, and hail rattled on the step. Then a man’s voice came from the turn of the service stair, low and calm, as though he had been standing there for a while.

“Which door?”

She looked up. He stood three steps from the bottom, in a dark coat, with a candle in one hand and a sheaf of papers in the other, as though he had come downstairs on some private errand and forgotten it. He was tall and lean, with short brown hair and a face that looked as though it had not known rest for a year. She knew at once who he must be, for no one else in that house would have dared interrupt Lady Griselda.

“Your Grace,” Mrs. Elsdon said.

“Which door, Miss Tennant?” Piers Heddon, Duke of Coldmarten, repeated. “Not whether you unlocked it. Which one, and why?”