Ten minutes later she found herself in a library that smelled of cold ashes and old leather, dripping upon an Oriental carpet, telling a duke what she had told no one. He did not sit before she did. He listened without interrupting.

Lady Beatrice Tyndall was nineteen. Her father had promised her to Sir Hamon Gryce, a man of fifty-eight with two dead wives and a great deal of coal beneath his land. Beatrice had refused. Her father had locked her in her room for eleven days. On the twelfth night, the night before the contracts were to be signed, Avis had taken the key from its hook in the study, where she had been told it must remain. She had unlocked the door and given Beatrice the fare for the coach to Edinburgh and the name of the inn in Belford where it stopped. Beatrice had been caught in Belford before dawn and brought home in her father’s carriage.

“And she did not clear your name,” the Duke said.

“No, Your Grace.”

“Why not?”

Avis looked at the cold grate.

“That is hers to tell. Not mine.”

He was silent for a moment.

“Did you take money for it?”

“I gave money for it. My own.”

“Would you do it again?”

She knew the right answer. She had known it for five months.

“Yes.”

“That is a very poor answer for a woman seeking employment.”

“It is the only honest answer I have, Your Grace. I thought it better that you should have it now than discover it afterward.”

Then he looked at her, truly, for the first time. Something crossed his face that was not quite a smile. He asked what she could teach. She answered: music, pianoforte and singing, French, history, geography, and the use of the globes.

“And accounts,” she added. “I kept Lady Tyndall’s household books for two years. She did not like figures.”

“My niece is ten,” the Duke said. “She has not touched the instrument since her mother died, and she does not speak to strangers. The last governess left in September because Tabitha had not spoken to her in four months. I can offer you forty pounds a year. It is less than you are worth, and a little more than this estate can easily afford at present.”

Avis opened her mouth to answer and found nothing to say.

“Mrs. Elsdon will show you,” he said. “I have a room for you.”

It was such a small thing: six words spoken in the tone a man used to discuss the weather. But she had spent five months being looked at through half-open doors. She had stood on steps in the rain while women decided she was unfit to sleep beneath their roofs. She had counted her shillings every night upon Mrs. Stott’s coverlet and divided them by the number of days. In all that time, no one had offered her anything without first making her prove that she deserved it.

Her hands began to shake. She put them in her lap, and they shook there. She tried to say thank you, but her throat closed on the first word. She pressed her lips together and stared hard at the fireguard, because she did not want, she absolutely did not want, to cry before a duke in his own library on the first night. He saw it. She knew he had seen it.

He did the kindest thing anyone had done for her in six months. Without a word, he rose, crossed to the window, and stood looking at the black glass with his hands behind his back, as though something in the dark garden required his entire attention.