It was George Lindley who brought the news to the Fenwicks’ house early on Friday morning with his hat still in his hand.

“She has gone,” he told Charles in the hall.

“May?”

“She left her ring on his desk and went home to her father. Henry will not say a word about why.”

George looked at him for a long moment.

“I thought you ought to know. Your sister called on May on Thursday.”

Charles was not a clever man, and he had never pretended to be, but he was not blind. He thought of Louisa asking Henry for a private word at the office. ‘It concerns Oxford.’ He thought of her coming down to breakfast humming, which she never did. He thought of a night six years ago in their rooms at Oxford when Henry had sat at the table writing a letter he never sent, and Charles, passing behind his chair, had seen the name on the envelope. He went upstairs without a word.

Louisa was kneeling at the grate in her room feeding papers into the fire. She turned at the sound of the door, saw his face and rose a little too quickly.

“Charles, you might knock.”

He crossed the room, reached past her into the grate, and pulled out the envelope that was just beginning to curl in the flames. He beat out the fire against his sleeve. It was scorched along one edge, but the handwriting was perfectly clear. “Miss May Dawson.”

“I know what you are doing, Louisa,” he said.

She lifted her chin and looked at him with wide, puzzled eyes.

“I have no idea what you mean.”

“I do not know fully what passed between you and Henry at Oxford,” Charles said, “and I do not wish to. But you must forget it. He is married, and he loves his wife. Anyone with eyes can see it. Do not shame me, and do not shame our family.”

Something flickered in Louisa’s face. She knew then that he knew, and her voice came out smaller than she meant it to.

“I did nothing,” she said. “I only showed her the letter.”

“The letter he wrote to her?”

“How was I to know who he wrote it to?” Louisa said quickly. “He never said her name, not once. If Henry had not been so free with his attentions back then, if he had not encouraged me.”

“Stop.”

Charles did not shout. He had never once raised his voice to his sister, and he did not raise it now, which was somehow far worse.

“Stop lying to me, Lou. Henry never encouraged you. You made yourself available, and he was too drunk and too miserable to send you away. You knew long before he ever said a word to you that there was a girl at home, and that she did not care for him the way he cared for her. You knew it was not you. You always knew.”

Louisa’s eyes filled. She turned away to the window so he would not see.

“You cannot make other people wretched because he will not love you that way,” Charles said quietly. “He never will, and I will not let you pour my oldest friendship down the drain for the sake of your pride. So, you will go to May today, and you will tell her the truth.”

“No.”

“Louisa.”

“No.”

She spun round, and her face was white.

“Go to her. Stand in her drawing-room and tell her I lied, and watch her look at me as though I am small and mean and pitiful? I will not, Charles. I will not let her see me so little.”

Her voice shook, but her chin came up.

“I am Louisa Fenwick, after all.”

Charles looked at his sister for a long moment. Then he looked down at the scorched envelope in his hand. If he went to Henry with it, he would have to tell his oldest friend exactly what his own sister had done, and Henry would never look at a Fenwick in quite the same way again.

But if he said nothing, May would stay in her father’s house. Henry would go on believing whatever terrible thing he believed, and two people who loved each other would lose everything over a letter that had never been posted. Charles put the envelope in his pocket, picked up his hat, and stood very still in the doorway, deciding.

Henry had not gone home that night. He had sat at his desk in the dark office until dawn, with May’s ring in one hand and her note in the other, reading five words over and over until they stopped meaning anything at all. “You are free, Henry. Be happy.” He did not look up when the door opened. He only looked up when Charles Fenwick laid a scorched envelope on the desk in front of him, very gently, as though he were laying down something that might still be alive.