“I have something to tell you,” Charles said, “and I would give a great deal not to have to.”
He told it all. He did not spare his sister, and he did not spare himself. Louisa taking the letter from their rooms at Oxford, Louisa keeping it for six years, Louisa calling on May on Thursday and telling her that she was the girl who had broken Henry’s heart, and that the letter had been written to her.
“I am ashamed,” Charles said at the end, and his voice cracked on it. “Of her and of myself for not seeing it sooner. If you never want a Fenwick in your house again, Henry, I will understand.”
But Henry was not listening anymore. He was staring at the envelope and at his own handwriting on it, and everything was falling into place the way ice breaks on a pond. ‘I already know I could not bear to hear it said out loud.’ She had not meant him. She had meant Louisa. She had stood beside the covered sign and begged him not to tell her that he loved another woman.
‘I know who it was meant for. I have been told.’ Louisa. Always Louisa. ‘Jealous of nothing, nothing at all.’ She had been jealous. She had stood right here in front of this desk jealous of a woman who had never meant anything to him.
And he had been too proud and too frightened to see it. He had asked her three times to give him a sign when she had been giving him one all along. She did not know. After everything, May still did not know.
Henry stood up so suddenly his chair went over behind him. He took the letter from where she had left it on his desk and put it in his breast pocket with the envelope. Then he picked up the ring. At the door he stopped and looked back at Charles, who was still standing by the desk waiting to be sent away.
“You came,” Henry said. “That is what matters. You will dine with us on Sunday.”
Charles looked at him as though he might weep. Henry did not wait to see it.
The Dawsons’ house was very quiet when he got there. The footman who opened the door took one look at the Duke’s face and stepped aside without a word. He found Lady Dawson in the corridor at the back of the house standing before the door of the little sitting room with one hand pressed flat against the wood. It was the same way she had stood outside the vestry on their wedding day as though she could reach her daughter through it. She turned when she heard him and her face was tired and frightened and very kind.
“She has been in there since yesterday morning,” she said quietly. “She will not come out and she will not tell me why.”
“Will you give us a moment?” Henry asked. “Please.”
This time, Lady Dawson did not hesitate. She looked at him for a long moment, and whatever she saw in his face made her eyes fill. She touched his arm once, gently, the way she had when he was a little boy with grass on his knees.
“Take as long as you need,” she said, and left them.
Henry stood alone before the door. Once before he had stood like this, on the worst morning of his life, not knowing what had happened to her or what he would say. This time he knew exactly. He had six years of it, and he was not going to swallow a single word. He raised his hand and knocked.
Henry waited. Somewhere in the house a clock was ticking, and on the other side of the door he could hear nothing at all, not a step, not a breath. He rested his forehead against the wood and closed his eyes.
“You do not have to open it,” he said quietly. “Once on our wedding night, I told you that the door between us locked from your side. That has not changed, May. Whatever door it is, I will not ask you to open it. I am only asking you to listen.”
Silence. But he thought, he was almost sure, that he heard her move a little closer.
“The letter was never hers, May.”
His voice was not steady, and he did not try to make it so.
“It was never anyone’s but yours.”
He took the scorched envelope from his breast pocket, knelt down, and slid it under the door.
On the other side, May was sitting on the floor with her back against the wall, exactly where she had been sitting for most of the night. She watched the envelope slide across the boards toward her, and for a long moment she could not make herself pick it up. When she did, she saw her own name in Henry’s hand.