Henry was quiet for a moment. Then he stood, straightened his coat, and held out his hand to her.
“Then there is something I have been waiting to do,” he said, “since I was 7 years old.”
Sir Walter Dawson was sitting at his desk pretending to read the newspaper when they came in. He had clearly not turned a page in an hour. He looked from his daughter’s swollen eyes to the Duke’s, and then down at their joined hands, and he set the newspaper aside very slowly. Henry stood before the desk, exactly as straight as a small boy with grass on his knees had once stood on the front step.
“Sir,” he said, “I would like to ask for your daughter’s hand.”
For a moment, Sir Walter only stared at him. Then his shoulders began to shake, and his face went red, and he laughed until he had to grip the arms of his chair.
“You great fool,” he wheezed, wiping his eyes. “You have already married her.”
“I know, sir, but I never asked you properly. Not since the first time.”
The laughter faded out of the old man’s face. He looked at Henry for a long moment, and then at May, and something in his eyes went very soft.
“20 years,” he said quietly. “20 years ago you stood on my step and asked me for her, and I sent you home for your supper. I have wondered ever since whether you would ever ask again.”
He held out his hand.
“Took you long enough, my boy.”
Henry shook it. May burst into tears all over again, and her father pretended not to notice, and blew his nose very loudly instead.
That evening, as the sun went down, Henry took May back to the New Street. The scaffolding was gone now. The 12 tall houses stood finished in the last of the light, their windows glowing gold. At the end of the street, the iron sign still leaned against the railings, wrapped in its sacking.
“I was going to show you this,” Henry said, “the night you told me not to say it.”
He pulled the sacking away. May read the name on the sign, and then she read it again, and then she put both hands over her mouth. “May Street.”
“Your father laid the first stones,” Henry said quietly. “I wanted the last thing on it to be you.”
She did not say anything at all. She simply walked into his arms in the middle of the empty street and stayed there until the lamplighter came by and pretended very politely not to see them.
They went back to the chapel on a quiet morning a month later with no crowd and no reason to pretend. It was not a wedding, for they were married already, and the Lord did not need to hear it twice, but they needed to say it, and the Reverend Mr. Gibbs, who had aged 10 years the last time, agreed to read a blessing over them. Only their families came, and George Lindley and Charles Fenwick, who cried through the whole service and did not care who saw. And this time, when Henry took her hand and spoke the words ‘Till death us do part,’ May said them back to him without a single tremble. When he slid the ring onto her finger, she looked up at him with a gleam in her eye.
“And what will you do,” she whispered, “if I drop it again?”
“Then I will pick it up,” said Henry. “Every time.”
As for the rest of them, Louisa Fenwick stayed in Bath, where she was said to be greatly admired and very rarely mentioned. Charles dined with the Duke and Duchess every Sunday for the rest of his life. The office cat was given a velvet cushion beneath the window between two desks that had been pushed very close together, and the key to the connecting door went to the bottom of the lake at the country estate, where Henry dropped it one summer afternoon while pretending to lose an oar, and the Dowager Duchess, well, before the year that Henry and May had once agreed upon was even out, she was sitting at the breakfast table knitting tiny white booties and looking very pleased with herself indeed.
So, I asked you at the very beginning what you would call two people who loved each other their whole lives and never once said so. Silly, perhaps. Clueless, certainly. But I think, in the end, I would simply call them afraid because sometimes the people closest to us are the ones we are most afraid to tell the truth.
We have the most to lose, so we hide behind a joke or a friendship or a single careless sentence in a garden and we let years go by. We let other people tell our story for us and we believe the worst because the worst feels safer than hope. May dropped that ring because she could not promise forever to a man she thought only wanted a year and he only offered her a year because he could not bear to keep her if she did not love him. Two people each trying to protect the other and both of them very nearly lost everything.