“You know, May, you have worked a miracle,” he said. “I never thought to see Henry settled, not after Oxford.”
“Charles,” said Henry.
“No, she ought to know what she has rescued.”
Charles waved his glass.
“That last spring he fell in love desperately. Never would tell me who she was, not even when he was in his cups. Some girl who told him she could never in her life think of him that way. It broke him clean in half. That was when the trouble started, the drinking and the gambling and the rest of it. He spent a whole year trying to forget her.”
The room had gone very quiet. May sat with a spoon halfway to her mouth. He had loved someone, truly loved her the way May had loved him, so much that losing her had broken him in half. And Henry, who told her everything, had never said one word about it. Across the table, George Lindley put down his glass and opened his mouth.
Henry did not even look at him. He simply set his boot down hard on George’s foot beneath the table, and George closed his mouth again. May did not see it. She was remembering a voice in a quiet sitting room, sweet as poison.
We all knew what Henry was at Oxford. Some of us knew him better than others, of course. It made a terrible kind of sense. A girl who would not have him then, and who had come back now, too late, smiling at him down the aisle of his own wedding.
That was why he had gone white in the chapel. That was why he lied about the drains. Henry had not been running from Louisa Fenwick. He had been running from how much he still wanted her.
“Well,” said George loudly into the silence, “he got over it, and he has wanted to marry May since he was seven, so I hardly think it counts.”
Charles roared.
“Seven?”
“Marched up to Mr. Dawson’s front door with grass all over his knees,” said George, “and asked for her hand. I was hiding in the hedge. Old Dawson laughed so hard he had to sit down on the step.”
The whole table laughed, even the dowager, and May laughed, too, because everyone was looking at her. She had spent her whole life pretending she did not want Henry, and she was very good at it by now.
“Thank heavens Papa said no,” she said brightly. “Imagine being married to Henry at seven. He would have made me play pirates every day for the rest of my life.”
Everyone laughed again. Henry smiled, too, but he set down his glass very carefully, and for a moment he did not look at her at all. And May, smiling across the candles at her husband, felt the last small, foolish hope inside her go out. A little boy with grass on his knees.
How sweet, but he had not been seven at Oxford. At Oxford, he had been a man, and he had given his whole heart to someone else. Henry had no idea that he had just lost her.
It was George who would not let it rest. He came into Henry’s office the next morning, closed the door behind him, and sat on the corner of the desk the way he had since they were boys.
“You stood on my foot,” he said.
“You were about to tell her.”
“Someone ought to.”
George leaned forward.
“Henry, I have watched you love that girl since we were in short trousers. Tell her the truth before you lose her to your own stubbornness.”
Henry said nothing for a long time. He was thinking of the letters in her writing box, worn soft as cloth. He was thinking of her voice in the dark. Did you never wonder why I never married anyone? And he was thinking of her laughing at the dinner table about pirates.
“And if she laughs?” he said at last.
“Then she laughs,” said George. “But at least you will know.”
So that evening, as the sun went down, Henry took May to see the new street. It ran along the edge of the estate. 12 tall houses still wrapped in scaffolding, the brick glowing warm in the last of the light. The workmen had gone home. It was very quiet, and May walked slowly along the pavement, looking up at the windows.
“They are beautiful, Henry,” she said softly. “Your father would have been so proud.”
“Your father laid the foundations,” Henry said, “before he gave up building. I wanted to finish what they started together.”
At the end of the street, covered in sacking and propped against the railings, stood a new iron street sign. Henry had chosen the name himself months ago and had not told a soul. He stopped beside it. His heart was beating so hard he could feel it in his throat.