“Miss May Dawson.” The door opened so suddenly that Henry nearly fell into the room. She stood there with the envelope crushed in her fingers, her eyes red and swollen, her hair coming down, and she looked at him as though she had never seen him before.
“It was for me,” she whispered, “every word. ‘But you said today that you could never think of me that way.'”
She was shaking now.
“Henry, I never said that to you. I never in my life said that to you.”
“Not to me.”
Henry’s throat was so tight he could barely speak.
“Easter, the spring before I went back to Oxford. I came up through your mother’s garden to find you. And you were sitting on the bench with her, and she was teasing you about me. And you laughed, May. You said, ‘Marrying Henry? It would be like marrying my brother.'”
May went white. She remembered. She had forgotten it completely. One silly sentence among a thousand. And now it came rushing back all at once.
The bench under the apple tree. Her mother smiling and saying, ‘You are very fond of that boy, my love.’ Her own heart pounding with terror that anyone might guess. And her own bright, careless voice saying the cruelest thing she could think of. So that no one ever would.
“I said that so no one would know,” she said.
Her voice broke completely.
“Henry, I said it because Mama was too close to the truth. I would have died before I let anyone guess how much I loved you. I have loved you since I was 12 years old.”
Henry made a sound that was not quite a word.
“You turned around,” May said, and the tears were coming now, and she could not stop them. “You heard that, and you turned around and went back to Oxford, and you thought for 6 years that I…”
“Yes.”
“And I thought…”
She pressed her hand to her mouth.
“Do you know why I dropped the ring? I was standing there, and the vicar said, ‘Til death us do part.’ And I could not say it. I could not stand before God and promise you forever, Henry, when you only wanted me for a year.”
“Only wanted you for a year?”
Henry stared at her.
“May, I never wanted a year. I gave you the year so you would never feel trapped with a man you did not love. So you could leave if you wanted to and never have to pretend. I would have given you forever. I have been trying to give you forever since I was 7 years old.”
And then Henry, who had never once cried in front of her, not when he broke his arm falling from the hayloft, not at his father’s funeral, not on the morning she ran from the altar, put his face in his hands and wept. May crossed the room to him. She took his wrists and drew his hands gently away from his face, and she held his wet cheeks between her palms the way he had once held her hands on their wedding night, steady and sure.
“They said you were a rake,” she whispered. “All of London, all those women.”
“Every woman in London looked at me, May.”
He covered her hands with his own.
“And I never once looked back because I was always looking at you.”
She laughed a small, broken, wonderful laugh with the tears still running down her face.
“Say it,” she said. “Please. Out loud. I have waited my whole life to hear you say it.”
Henry looked down into her face, the face he had known since before he knew the word for love.
“I love you,” he said. “I loved you at 7 on your father’s doorstep. I loved you at Oxford when I thought you would never love me back. I loved you in that vestry and at that altar and in the dark with your hand in mine every single night. I love you, May. I always have and I always will.”
She kissed him then or he kissed her. Neither of them was ever quite sure afterwards. It did not matter. It was 6 years too late and exactly on time.
When at last they drew apart, Henry opened his hand. Her wedding ring lay in his palm warm from being held so long. May looked at it and then at him and held out her hand. He slid it onto her finger slowly, carefully, and this time she did not let it fall.
It was May who remembered her father.
“Henry,” she said a long while later with her head on his shoulder and her ruined hair spilling everywhere. “Papa is in the study. He will have heard the door.”