Henry did not sit down, and he did not offer Louisa a chair.

“Say what you came to say, Miss Fenwick.”

“Miss Fenwick?” Louisa repeated, amused.

She wandered to the window and looked down into the square.

“You used to call me Lou.”

“I used to drink a great deal, too. I gave up both.”

She smiled softly.

“You were so unhappy that last spring at Oxford. Do you remember? Some girl back home who would not have you. You never would tell me her name. You drank and you talked and you wrote, and I was the one who sat up with you through all of it.”

“I was a fool,” Henry said. “You were kind to a fool for a few weeks, and I have regretted every moment of it since. It is over, Louisa. It was over before it began.”

“Is it?”

She turned from the window.

“I still have your letter, Henry.”

For a moment, Henry did not move at all. Then the color left his face so completely that even Louisa looked faintly surprised. He knew exactly which letter she meant.

He had written it on the worst night of that terrible spring and never sent it. When he came down from Oxford, it was gone and he had looked for it for 6 years before telling himself it must have been burned with the rubbish. He had prayed it had been.

“Your wife seems a sweet little thing,” Louisa said lightly, drawing on her gloves. “It would be such a pity if she ever read it. Do think about that. I only want you to remember that I know you, Henry, better than she ever will.”

Out in the main office, May had been staring at the same line of the same ledger for 11 minutes. She knew it was 11 because she had counted them on the clock above Mr. Pike’s head. In the first minute, she imagined them discussing the lease very dully. By the fourth minute, Louisa had her hand on Henry’s arm.

By the seventh, May was quite certain they were embracing beside the window. And by the ninth, she had pictured herself flinging open the door, marching in with the cat held out in front of her like a pistol, and saying something so cutting that Louisa fled down the stairs in tears. The cat, who was asleep on her feet, would probably not have cooperated.

“Tea, Your Grace?” Mr. Pike asked kindly.

“Yes,” said May. “No, thank you. Is that clock fast?”

The door opened. Louisa came out first, smiling, and wished every clerk in the room a very good afternoon. She gave May a little nod, the kind one gives to a pleasant servant, and swept out with Charles behind her, still chattering about drains. Henry stood in his doorway.

His face was perfectly calm, but May had known that face all her life. She saw how white it was beneath the calm. She followed him into his office and closed the door.

“What did she want?”

“The lease,” Henry said, sitting down and pulling a stack of papers toward him. “A question about the drains.”

“The drains?” May repeated.

“Yes, the house has had trouble with them. Barnes will see to it.”

He said it so easily, without hesitating and without looking up. And for one moment May almost believed him. That was the worst part. Henry had always been a terrible liar, as bad as she was, and now he lied as smoothly as he signed his name, as if he had been practicing for years. May went back to her desk and sat down.

And she did not see a single figure in the ledger for the rest of the afternoon. Two weeks ago she had lied to him about curtains. Now he had lied to her about drains. And May, who had always believed she knew every corner of Henry’s heart, began to wonder how many rooms in it he had kept locked.

The Dowager Duchess came to dine on their third evening back in London, and she brought her questions with her.

“I trust the country air agreed with you both,” she said over the soup in a voice that made it perfectly clear she was not asking about the air.

“Oh, very much,” said May. “It was very fresh, very healthy. Everything was growing beautifully. The orchards and the hedges and the sheep. The sheep were enormously fertile.”

She heard herself and stopped.

“The soil. I meant the soil is very fertile.”

Henry choked on his wine. George Lindley seated beside him became suddenly fascinated by his spoon. Charles Fenwick, who had come without his sister, was shaking with silent laughter into his napkin.

“How reassuring,” said the Dowager.

It was Charles who saved her. Though May would later wish with her whole heart that he had not. By the time the pudding arrived he had drunk a good deal of Henry’s claret, and he leaned back in his chair with the warm misty look of a man about to tell a story.