Anne stood motionless in the white, cold yard. From behind the half-open stall door, the bay filly put out her head and blew warm breath against Anne’s face, bright-eyed and annoyed at being kept waiting for breakfast.

Anne looked at the bucket of bran mash and the brown bottle. Then she looked at the disheveled man who had spent the whole night on a bucket in the cold, because he had seen something she had been too sure of herself to see.

At first she said nothing. She went to him, took both his frozen hands, drew them beneath her shawl, and held them as she had held the old woman’s hands beside the fire. She held them a long time, until she felt warmth begin to return to his fingers. He did not move. He only looked at her with surprised, silent hazel eyes.

“You were right,” Anne said at last. “And I was wrong, and the filly might have paid for it. You had better get your chisel out for that stable door.”

His mouth twitched.

“I’ll fetch it tomorrow,” Edward said. “Today I’d rather keep this moment.”

The October fair at Bakewell filled the town from the bridge to the church. Sheep stood in pens along the riverbank, and cattle crowded the smaller lanes. There were gingerbread stalls, a fiddler on the bridge, and more horses than Anne had ever seen gathered in one place. They came in droves from every valley of the Peak, while dealers stood among them in long coats, patting necks, testing movement, and lying cheerfully to one another.

The judging ring was a square of hurdles in the meadow below the bridge. Three old farmers and a landowner sat behind a table at one end, with a barrel of ale beside them to assist their deliberations.

Anne brought the four Marsh Court horses into the ring a little before noon, one after another, with the bay filly last. She wore her dark-green dress, carefully brushed, and the horses wore her father’s plain snaffle bits. Her father stood by the fence with his hat in his hands. Edward stood beside him, and the crowd, which had heard what happened in the night, pressed closer to watch.

Hugh Normhurst let Anne take the filly halfway round the ring. Then he climbed onto the back of a cart beside the fence where everyone could see him and raised his voice.

“Gentlemen, before you wager a single penny on these horses, I’ve something to say, and I am very sorry to have to say it.”

He looked sorry. It was a talent of his.

“In July that bay filly put two grooms into a water trough. Ask anybody. Now she follows a girl round like a lamb after its mother. There is only one thing in Derbyshire that can do that to a wild horse in eight weeks, and it comes in a brown bottle. Ask yourselves…”

“…where Chanstone’s daughter learned her trade.”

A murmur traveled round the ring like wind across a field of barley. Two dealers at the front turned away and spat. The landowner behind the judges’ table set down his mug and frowned.

“That’s a serious accusation, Normhurst.”

“It’s the truth,” Hugh Normhurst replied.

Anne did not answer him. She stopped the bay filly in the middle of the ring and unfastened her bridle. Gently she slipped it over the filly’s ears and took her father’s plain snaffle out of the mare’s mouth. Then she walked to the fence and placed the bridle in Edward’s hands.

The entire ring fell quiet. An unbridled filly at a crowded fair, with dogs, cattle drovers, and a fiddler on the bridge, was a filly that might go anywhere.