“Come down, Your Grace,” Anne said.

He climbed down. He stood before her at the foot of the ladder, broad-chested and untidy, paint on his cuffs and the chisel still in his hand. She noticed he wore no gloves. He said nothing. He had already said what he needed to say beneath the apple trees. Then he had waited, and was waiting still.

“You told me that if there were ever a question between us,” Anne said, “I would have to be the one to ask it.”

“I did.”

“I thought about that all night. I’ve decided I was wrong about the county, wrong about your mother, and wrong about you sitting up with that filly. That’s three times in one week. For someone like me it’s a very great deal.”

Her voice trembled a little. She made no attempt to stop it.

“So I’ve decided to try letting someone else be right. Just this once, about the one thing that truly matters.”

She took the chisel from his hand and laid it on a rung of the ladder. Then she took both his hands in hers.

“Edward, will you marry me?”

Until that moment she had only ever seen his face turn toward her, open and attentive. Now she saw something come over him. He stood motionless, his hazel eyes bright, all the restless thoughts that usually took flight in his head settling upon her at once.

“Yes,” Edward said. “Yes. I had meant to say something about the weather, and then about the paint, and then a very long and quite interesting thing about Xenophon. But yes. That’s all. Yes.”

He kissed her there at the foot of the ladder, in the empty stable yard, where the late sun touched the cobbles and all the golden valley stretched below. At first it was a gentle kiss, and then it was not particularly gentle at all. When they finally drew apart, he rested his forehead against hers and laughed softly.

“Now I shall have to leave that sign there,” he said.

“I know,” Anne said. “I’ll get used to it.”

The banns were read three times in the little church at Monkdale, and in the first week of December Anne Chanstone married the Duke of Edingham before the whole village. Her father walked her down the aisle in his best coat, stepping very slowly on his aching knees, and looking very proud.

The dowager duchess sat in the front pew in silk and pearls. Around her shoulders was the brown woolen shawl that no one in the church, except the bride, could explain.

The second October after the wedding came with apples and fog. On a Tuesday morning the kitchen at Marsh Court smelled of fresh bread and woodsmoke. Anne sat beside the hearth with her daughter in her lap. The baby was five months old, had her father’s hazel eyes and her grandmother’s opinions, and was chewing one of her father’s gloves, which had been missing since Michaelmas.

Edward sat at the table reading a list of Greek verbs to his daughter in his gentle voice, while she ignored every word. A knock sounded at the kitchen door. Anne crossed the room and opened it. On the threshold, amid the white fog, stood an old woman in a brown cloak worn thin at the shoulders, her hood pulled low.

She carried a basket in one hand.

“Spare an old woman a crust of bread, miss,” said the Dowager Duchess of Edingham, her black eyes twinkling, “and God will spare you another.”

“Come in, mother,” Anne said, laughing. “You’re just in time.”

She led the older woman straight through the kitchen to the oak armchair with its patched red cushion, the chair brought up the hill from her father’s house along with the good cup, and settled her beside the fire. She put her granddaughter into the duchess’s lap. Then she took the blue-and-white cup down from the highest shelf, filled it, and placed it in the old woman’s hands before pouring one for herself.