Miss Lowe said it without complaint, as one states the depth of a river.

“I make it do.”

Avis looked at her hands, her patched shawl, and the once-good shoes that had been resoled three times.

“You make it do with your own money.”

Miss Lowe did not answer, which was an answer. At the back of the room, at the end of the last bench, a twelve-year-old boy with red hair and a face like an axe was doing long division in his head faster than Miss Lowe could write it on the board.

“James Bell,” the schoolmistress said, following her gaze. “Thomas’s grandson. The best head I have ever had in this room. He comes two days a week now, when he can. His father broke his leg at harvest, and the family was refused relief, so James works at Pringle’s farm the rest of the week.”

“Refused?” Avis said. “By whom?”

“Mr. Crowe told them His Grace had made a rule. No relief for a family behind with its rent.”

On the way back to the house, Avis sat beside Thomas Bell on the cart and said nothing for a kilometer. Tabitha slept against her shoulder. The child had spent the afternoon beside a little girl named Hannah, sharing her slate and laughing aloud when Hannah drew a pig.

“Mr. Bell,” Avis said at last, “was your son’s family refused relief this autumn?”

The old man drove on for a while.

“We do not trouble His Grace. He has enough to worry him.”

“That is not what I asked.”

“They were refused.”

Thomas Bell flicked the reins.

“Mr. Crowe said it was His Grace’s order. I have known Master Piers since he was small, and I never knew him give an order like that. But it is not for me to judge.”

“And what do you think of Mr. Crowe?”

The gardener was silent so long that she thought he would not answer.

“Mr. Crowe is a careful man, miss,” he said at last. “A very careful man. And careful men, in my experience, keep a duplicate of everything.”

She did not run straight to the Duke. She had already been dismissed once for being right too soon and too loudly. She had learned that a truth spoken without evidence was only a well-meaning rumor. So she went back to the school twice. On the second visit she asked Miss Lowe whether she kept a record of what she received. The schoolmistress looked surprised, then a little proud.

“My mother kept a shop in Alnwick. She taught me to sign for everything and keep the receipts.”

She took a sewn account book from the shelf above her desk.

“Every quarter’s payment since I came six years ago. Every sack of coal, every slate. All three of them.”

“Would you lend it to me?”

“Why, Miss Tennant?”

Avis told her the truth.

“I want to be certain of something before I speak to anyone. And if I am wrong, I want to be the only person who knows it.”

Her chance came a week before Christmas. The Duke came to the schoolroom door one afternoon, as he sometimes did, and stayed to hear Tabitha play a scale with her tongue between her teeth. When the child went to show Mrs. Elsdon her new hyacinths, he lingered.

“She played for you,” he said. “She has not played since.”

He stopped.

“You have done in six weeks what I could not do in two years.”

“I only played the wrong note, Your Grace. She did the rest.”

He almost smiled.

“Is there anything you want for her? Books? Music? I am told I must ask.”

“There is something I want for the school,” Avis said.

She told him of the three slates, the empty grate, and the boy who did long division in his head. She told it simply and watched his face change.

“That is not possible,” he said. “The school has forty pounds a year from the estate, besides a separate fund for the parish poor. I signed the allowance myself when I inherited. I have signed it every quarter since.”

“Miss Lowe receives eight pounds a quarter, Your Grace. Thirty-two pounds a year. She has signed for every penny.”