And as he spoke, he signed it slowly, clumsily, the way she had taught him in the gallery. Steady always. Yes. And at the end, two fingers to his lips and then to his heart. Her mother’s sign for her father.

Finella looked at it a long moment. And then she made it back to him.

“I love you too,” she said aloud for the whole room. “I have since you forgave the widow’s rent and didn’t tell anybody.”

“You read that?”

“I read everything.”

And there, under the three chandeliers, with the fiddles playing and the county watching, Ivo took his wife’s face in his hands and kissed her.

Lady Ursula Bellingham lived out her days in Bath, in good rooms, on a good allowance, and was received by fewer people every season, because the story of Christmas Eve had followed her there. Lady Petronella Radley went abroad that summer and did not come back to the valley. Sir Eustace Radley found that the county’s doors had all learned to close. And in the end he let Radley Court and went to live in the north where nobody asked him to dinner.

Nobody at Oakhurst ever again said a word behind a fan about Margery Garside’s daughter. And ever after at every ball and every dinner and every long dull sermon, the Duke and Duchess of Oakhurst talked to each other across crowded rooms without a sound, and nobody else ever knew what they said. But the footman swore they could always tell. He would turn his face full toward her from the far end of any room, and his lips would move. And the duchess who could read him across any room in England would smile and lay two fingers on her lips and then on her heart.