The vicar’s wife put her hand to her mouth. The old baronet from across the valley went red to the ears. The two footmen by the door looked at the carpet. Petronella looked at her brother’s ring on her finger and did not look up. Ursula found her voice.

“This is absurd. The girl has been listening at doors.”

“I’ve never listened at a door in my life, aunt. I can’t hear through doors any better than you can.”

Finella’s voice did not rise.

“I have only ever sat where you put me with my eyes open.”

At the window, the Duke had not moved. He was looking at his aunt.

Finella saw him hear it at last in his own drawing room before his own neighbors. Paid for, his aunt had said. She saw him take the words one at a time, the way a man takes stones out of his pocket. He looked at Ursula a long moment. His aunt looked back and what he read in her face he did not say.

Then he crossed the room to his wife.

“Nathaniel,” he said without turning his head. “Go to the pianoforte. Play something slow.”

Nathaniel went. The keys were cold and the first notes came out wrong. And then they came out right. An old slow air, the kind the county danced to before the war.

Ivo held out his hand to his wife in front of everyone.

“Madam,” he began and stopped and began again. “Finella, will you dance with me?”

She looked at his hand. She took it. It was the first dance of their marriage. The drawing room was not made for dancing, and the guests had to pull their chairs back against the walls, and the holly caught at her hem. None of it mattered.

He danced stiffly, like a man who had forgotten how. She danced as if she had never been tired in her life. On the first turn, he bent his head to speak close to her ear.

“You needn’t whisper,” she said. “Face me. I can read you from here or from the other end of the room.”

He straightened and turned his face full to hers so she could see every word.

“Good evening, Finella.”

“Good evening, Ivo.”

“How long?”

“Since I was five.”

“Everything,” he said.

It was not a question.

“Everything you said where I could see your face.”

He missed a step. She did not let him fall out of the figure. She simply turned and brought him round with her and they went on.

When the music ended, Lady Ursula was gone from the sofa. Nobody had seen her leave. Petronella had gone too, and the harp stood alone under the candles with its strings still humming. The guests left early that Christmas Eve. They left quickly and quietly, and not one of them could look at the Duchess when they said good night, and every one of them was trying to remember what exactly they had said in her sight.