That night the Duke sat late in the library with the fire going down, and his cousin sat across from him with his boots on the fender.

“Tell me one thing about her,” said Nathaniel.

“About whom?”

“Don’t. Your wife. Tell me one thing you know about her that you didn’t learn from her father’s banker.”

Ivo was quiet for a long time. The fire ticked. At last, he said, “The morning of the wedding, I asked her if her father had made her do it. I thought she would say yes. Everyone says yes. It lets both parties off. And she said, ‘No, Your Grace. I chose it. I thought you had an honest face.'”

He turned his glass in his hand.

“I have not been able to think of a single thing to say to her since.”

“You might start with that.”

“With what?”

“Madam, I regret to inform you that my face is a liar.”

He set the glass down.

“Leave it. She has her rooms and her menus and her letters from Halifax. She’s not unhappy.”

“How would you know?”

The Duke had no answer, so he gave none.

The next Sunday, the vicar and his wife dined at Oakhurst with two neighboring families and old Sir Osbert from across the valley. And when Finella came down, she found that her place had been moved again. She was no longer at the foot of the table. She was halfway up one side between the vicar’s deaf uncle and a bowl of hothouse grapes. Ursula caught her eye and smiled.

“I thought you’d be more comfortable out of the draft, my dear.”

“How kind, aunt.”

Then Ursula turned to the vicar’s wife and lifted her fan and said behind it, “Poor creature. She can’t follow half of what’s said at a table, you know. We seat her where she can’t embarrass herself.”

The vicar’s wife made a sound of pity. Finella ate her soup. Across the grapes, Petronella was talking to the Duke. She talked well. She talked about Bath and the Regent and a new novel, and she laughed at the right places, and she had a way of touching his sleeve on the last word of every sentence.

And then, clearly for the table,

“Your Grace, the Duchess told me only yesterday that she finds Oakhurst very dreary. She longs for Halifax. Don’t you, Duchess?”

The table turned. Finella saw the Duke’s face go still and cold, the way it went when a tenant told him the rain had spoiled a harvest. She saw him believe it. She set down her spoon.

“I never said so, Lady Radley,” she said.

In 5 weeks she had not contradicted anyone at Oakhurst aloud until now. Her voice was low and plain with Yorkshire still in the vowels, and it carried further than she meant. Petronella laughed prettily.

“Oh, my dear, you must have forgotten. We were in the morning room.”

“I remember the morning room. You asked if I missed my father. I said I did. I didn’t say anything about Oakhurst.”